Page 1 of 1

Woman faces 5 years jail for being victim of practical joke

Posted: Tue May 19, 2009 2:57 am
by Merinda
Hi Ladies ,

This is a current issue :

An Australian mother-of-four facing five years in a Thai jail for allegedly stealing a bar mat has accused police of targeting her because she was with a group of women.

Annice Smoel spent four nights in a cramped jail cell in Phuket with three other inmates and feels "scared, helpless and alone" after being detained for what she says was a practical joke pulled by her friends.

A holiday in Phuket for her mother's 60th birthday turned into a nightmare on May 2 when she was at the popular Aussie Bar where she says two friends put the bar mat in her handbag.

Undercover police arrested the Melbourne woman and charged her with "night time theft", an offence that carries a higher punishment than day time theft.

Smoel, 36, was bailed after four days in jail but might have to wait 14 weeks in Thailand before she appears in court.

If found guilty, she could face between two and five years in jail.

Talking to reporters in a phone hook up from Phuket, Smoel, from Montrose in Melbourne's east, broke down.

"It's totally unbelievable," she told reporters.

When asked how she was coping away from her daughters Zhian, 12, Daisy, 11, Zoe, eight and Lilly, six, she started crying.

"I just want to come home to my kids. They're terrified and they are scared," she said.

"I really want to be a good mum."

She has missed a daughter's appendix operation, another's birthday and Mother's Day.

She pleaded with the Australian government for help.

"You've got to help me. I haven't done anything, it was all just a set up and a crock," she said.

She believes the only reason the incident has got to this stage is because "we were women on our own".

She says it wouldn't have escalated if there were men with the group.

But the owner of the Aussie Bar, Steve Wood, believes Smoel had been abusive toward the undercover police who had stopped her in the bar.

"When they talked to her all they wanted to do was chastise her, and they usually let you go. But she did a runner on them ... The police had to chase her down the beach," Mr Wood told Fairfax Radio Network.

"When they took her back to the police station, she continued to abuse everyone at the police station including the chief of police and I think this is what the problem is."

Police even refused bribes from Smoel, telling her she must report in every fortnight for the next 14 weeks.

"We offered them money right from the start, because we knew that's the way the system works over here and they wouldn't take it," Ms Smoel said.

Her husband Darren rushed to Thailand from Melbourne after her arrest.

He described the situation as a "complete joke" and told the government to "sort it out".

"I'm not leaving here without her, it's as simple as that," he told reporters via phone link.

"Nobody's putting my wife in jail, I'll tell you that. I will do whatever I have to do to get her out of here."

Lawyer Bernard Murphy said he didn't believe a crime had been committed.

"Let's take the worst view that it was a drunken souveniring of a bar mat: deport her, charge her, get her home, no issue," Mr Murphy told reporters.

"To date we are getting nowhere. It is a really important test for the department of foreign affairs and the minister, Stephen Smith, to take steps and intervene and fix this problem."

He said that if Smoel was an American, "she'd already be home".

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd insisted consular officials in Thailand were "providing every level of assistance" to Smoel and her family.

Posted: Tue May 19, 2009 7:29 am
by Absaroka
On one hand it looks like police stupidity, on the other hand everyone in jail is innocent. Since all we know is what we read in the press who knows what really happened.

I had friends when I was a teenager who always felt they had to mouth off to the police. Of course they were the ones who got arrested and got beat up while those of us who were quiet were left alone. I'm not saying they should have been beaten by the cops but it's just stupid to mouth off to someone with a gun and a badge. Also stupid to run, especially in 3rd world countries.

I'm saying this as someone who for many years seemed to fit some sort of description .......

Absaroka

Posted: Tue May 19, 2009 7:49 am
by DonnaT
We see people all the time on the TV show Cops who get drunk and act stupid around the police. Then they don't understand why they get arrested.

Posted: Tue May 19, 2009 3:30 pm
by Merinda
Absaroka wrote: Since all we know is what we read in the press who knows what really happened.

it's just stupid to mouth off to someone with a gun and a badge. Also stupid to run, especially in 3rd world countries.

Absaroka
I listened to the womans account , the bar owners account and witnesses account of what happened on talk-back radio , so I get a reasonable picture by putting the pieces together.

I agree that it is stupidity to mouth off at police even if innocent , however 4 days jail is ample for disrespect.
To remove her pasport and hold her in the country for a possible 2-5 year jail term is totally ridiculous.

If this happened here in Australia she would have been told to place the item back on the bar once her friends confessed that they did it as a joke , any drunken disrespect to police that followed may have resulted in her spending 1 night in the slammer and let go in the morning.
I understand that its different in other countries but "Hell" lets just give her the death penalty and be done with it.

4 days jail is enough , deport her .

The woman claims that she didn't run from the police , she claims that she'd thought the matter had been dealt with and over , she said that she ran accross the road to get shelter from the torrential rain and was then arrested.
The reason she raised her voice at police was at the police station where she was ordered to sign a statratry declaraion , the stat dec was written in thai and she couldn't read it , she argued for an interprator and got one who couldn't string 3 or more English words together.
She signed it and wrote "I dont understand Thai" , she was then charged.

Wheather you believe her story or not there are 2 undisputed facts :

(1) Her friends were resposible for putting the mat in her bag when she left the table to speak to people on another table.
(2) The mat was not removed from the premisses , thus no theft took place.

The 2 friends have not been charged with anything despite having being witnessed by the undercover police.

Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 6:26 am
by Absaroka
Sort of like the boy who got caned in Singapore for grafitti a few years ago. Totally out of proportion but people need to remember where they are. Her friends also needed to remember that they were guests in that country.

Posted: Wed May 20, 2009 3:06 pm
by Merinda
Absaroka wrote:Sort of like the boy who got caned in Singapore for grafitti a few years ago. Totally out of proportion but people need to remember where they are. Her friends also needed to remember that they were guests in that country.
Yes , but if anyone had to be arrested it should have been her 2 friends , she did nothing wrong to start with.

Anyway it has just been reported that she has been free'd and will return home as soon as possible.