Page 1 of 2

New Insights on Why I Crossdress

Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2005 5:45 pm
by Maggie
For more than two years I have been seeing a therapist in an attempt to figure out the meaning of my crossdressing and move beyond it. I have reviewed records and memories of my early childhood and gathered additional information from relatives. I also recently had a mind-blowing encounter with an incredibly perceptive spiritual healer, which provided an additional perspective. I think I am finally getting close to figuring out a reason for my crossdressing, which I would like to share.

What I am about to say is about my own individual situation. It may have no relevance whatsoever to other men who crossdress. While we all have things in common, I also respect the fact that we also have a wide variety of differences in our personal histories and degrees of gender identification.

Whether or not I was born with transgender tendencies is open to question. As a little boy I did not exhibit any transgender tendencies, nor was I ever crossdressed. However, I did suffer significant physical and emotional abuse. My mother kept a detailed, typewritten log of my first 5 years, which expressly states that she and my father began beating me with a leather belt when I was only about 18 months old. This continued for years. My parents would beat me severely, simply for routine things like crying or having temper tantrums - behavior that is perfectly normal for children that age. The stressful situation was further complicated when we moved into my grandmother's house, where I had to put up with the demands not only of my parents, but numerous other relatives.

I have been told that abused children often react by splitting off their emotions from the traumatic situation. This may have happened to me. In addition, such children tend to blame themselves for what is happening to them, rather than recognizing the terrifying truth about their abusive parents.

Then something good happened when I was about 3 1/2 years old. A female cousin my age came with her mother to live with us in my grandmother's house, while her father and mine were both serving in the armed forces. Her mother (my aunt) objected to my mother’s beating me, and my cousin and I were allowed to run around, make noise, and play happily together like normal children. My cousin initiated the activities, and I followed along. I became very attached to her, because through her I could freely enjoy and express myself as never before. Perhaps I also came to believe that girls had privileges that boys didn’t have.

When I was about 4 1/2 years old, my cousin and her family moved away. I missed her deeply. I found myself back in a world of impossible adults, terrifying beatings, and severe emotional repression. I felt like a frightened, frustrated, empty shell, trying to please the grownups around me. I was separated from my true feelings, which resided instead in an "imaginary playmate" that I had patterned after my girl cousin.

In the same town I also had a boy cousin my age, but with whom I had a competitive relationship. We both started kindergarten together, and that Halloween he came to school dressed as a girl, wearing a frilly blue dress and bonnet. This was my first contact with crossdressing. I was dumfounded. I was also surprised at how jealous I felt. Perhaps I unconsciously saw crossdressing as a way to achieve emotional fulfillment by merging with my idealized female persona.

Later, my father became annoyed when I persisted in talking about my cousin's costume. He angrily confronted me by asking whether I wanted to wear a dress. Sensing his disapproval, I lied and told him "No."

Around that time my sister was born, and I think I may also have been jealous of the attention that was being given to her.

For several years I denied and suppressed my interest in crossdressing. Then, when I was 11 years old, my best friend, who lived across the street from me, came down with a respiratory infection. He lived with his divorced mother, who was a Christian Scientist and did not believe in doctors. His illness became critical, and by the time she decided to seek medical attention, it was too late. He died on the way to the hospital.

I was deeply shaken by this event. During the following months, I found myself alone at home for a few hours each afternoon after school, with no other boys in the neighborhood to play with. One day I found a bag of my mother's discarded cotton dresses in the basement. Although I was initially afraid of compromising my "masculinity" by trying on female clothing, l eventually succumbed to my curiosity. Suddenly - wham! I felt a flood of euphoria springing from within me, washing away the stress and self-loathing that I had been enduring for years. Even on a purely physical level, I found that loose skirts and dresses were far more comfortable than trousers.

Needless to say, I was hooked. But with this pleasure also came the shame, guilt, and fear of rejection connected with male-to-female crossdressing. So I kept my crossdressing hidden and private. Even in socially acceptable contexts - such as Halloween, Boy Scout and fraternity skits, and womanless beauty contests - I repeatedly refused the opportunity to dress up as a woman in public.

For long periods my interest in crossdressing would diminish, only to re-emerge at times of emotional crisis and loneliness. One such period occurred when I was living alone in an apartment and began dressing in full drag for the first time. That is when I gave my female persona the name "Maggie." After a few months I met my present wife, I purged all my female things, and I swore off crossdressing for many years. However, I did wear men’s kilts for reasons of comfort.

The current manifestation of Maggie began almost three years ago, at another time of emotional crises. This time, I have expressed my female persona more fully than before. I have presented her as characters in stage performances, have taken her to TG support group meetings, and have gone about in public as a woman.

Like the girl cousin whom I loved when I was four, Maggie has helped me get through rough times. She removes the pall of fear, pain, and repression and allows me to experience inner wholeness and joy. It’s not that I enjoy being a woman per se, but rather that, when I am Maggie I am able to love myself. Now, if I could only learn to do this as a man.

Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2005 6:21 pm
by Claire D
Maggie, after reading your tremendus post. I felt my heart go out to you and all of the pain and sorrow that you have suffered. I can understand the reasons why I crossdress and the stress that is lifted off and away. Just as you yourself feel the same lifting of stress and the pleasure of being loved, and pain free. Even though our worlds may never meet, except for here in this forum. I do sincerly hope that you find all of the joy and happeness that you can handle.

Hugs, Claire

Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2005 8:12 pm
by Absaroka
Maggie that was a very moving post.

I don't think that much about why I cross dress anymore. I remember being told that in life, understanding is the booby prize. However understanding can lead to acceptance so it is a useful tool. Plus like a typical man I like to figure things out, including this.

Although I was not abused as a child there was something I related to. My moms clothes being a manifestation of her. I felt close to her so I felt close to her clothes. That simple.

Thank you for sharing your experience with us

Andrea

Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2005 9:23 pm
by Maggie
I would like to expand on one thing concerning my post. I suspect that, like many of you, I may have had some congenital predisposition toward transgenderism.

The spiritual healer that I mentioned said that, when she first saw me at a dinner party, she immediately sensed that my male and female sides were equally balanced. Unlike most people, who are predominately one or the other, I was 50-50. She also immediately knew that I was a crossdresser. She later told me that I was a shaman, and that I had a tremendous amount of spiritual energy that needed to be expressed.

I later e-mailed her a picture of Maggie. The spiritual healer responded that the picture confirmed what she had expected - that because of my nature and my repression, my soul and all of my energy and radiance resided in Maggie. She suggested that my goal now should be to invest my male side with similar power. I would like to do that, if I only knew how.

Posted: Mon Aug 01, 2005 10:27 pm
by Sallee
Maggie
Very good analysis about why you cross dress. I especially like your last post about the shaman. I find that very interesting and maybe with more truth in it than any of us want to realize. We all have an amount of female & male in us the yin yang. I guess some of us (the cders) have more than others....thanks...Sallee :-k

Posted: Tue Aug 02, 2005 4:46 am
by Cathy L. Anderson
Hi Maggie,

Thank you for your very thoughtful post. It seems like you have a good handle on the origin of your CDing and what you gain from it.
Maggie wrote:suggested that my goal now should be to invest my male side with similar power. I would like to do that, if I only knew how
Perhaps one strategy is to understand and define as specifically as possible those qualities which you experience as a female but not a male.

Another technique I use is to get deeply into being Cathy, pick some aspect of my experience as her, and then (as her), ask, "now how would it be to experience this as my male self?"

I also increasingly experiment with imagining myself as Cathy even while dressed as a man.

One of the most helpful things has been to think of myself more often as neither my female nor male part, but rather to identify with the person who is trying to help bring about an integration of the two. But, as mentioned in some of my other recent posts, I don't try to control this too much. Rather, I try to observe and cooperate with the actions of my higher Self in bringing this about.

Carl Jung described a technique called "active imagination"-- which uses directed imagination in various ways to help effect integration of conflicting parts of the psyche. There is no fixed technique--rather, it is left up to one's intuitition to play and experiment to find something that helps. I'm trying to learn more about this--if I do, I'll try to post something in the forum. Anyway, this seems like a promising lead.
Sallee wrote:We all have an amount of female & male in us the yin yang. I guess some of us (the cders) have more than others
The Taoist tradition, from which the terms yin and yang derive (I think) also has a system of alchemy for integrating or transmuting these energies. It's a bit like yoga. The system is described, for example, in the book, "The Secret of the Golden Flower." It's also like shamanism, in a way.

Cathy

Posted: Tue Aug 02, 2005 9:34 am
by Virginia
I can remember some of Maggie's early posts when whe was struggling with coming to terms with who she really was and if memory serves, she denied Maggie and recognized her only as a character she played, but questioned why she enjoyed Maggie so much! Girl has come a long way, and we are proud to call her one of our own!!!
As for the "balance" aspect and as Cathy as posed the transfer of Cathy to her "en drab" intercourse with society. I to have studied that and I have of late found more and more of Virginia in my "en drab" encounters. I tend to listen "better." A slight tilt of the head, a bit of leaning into the conversation, a gentle "knowing smile," and most of all the want to reach out and gently touch another human being - not sexually, but just to confirm "yes I see you, hear you and I enjoy you!" People resond so postively to that it is amazing!!!! Now if I can just get it to come even more naturally!!
Keep the faith, girls!
Virginia

Posted: Tue Aug 02, 2005 11:22 am
by Anita
Hi Maggie--
A very touching post, and painful to read at times. As for balance--if the spiritual healer cannot work with you herself, perhaps she can suggest someone who can. What you're seeking can be taught.

In trying to do it myself, I continually run across expectations of how a man is supposed to act. Some of them are my expectations, some are the ones I was taught, and some are other people's. It doesn't matter where one begins and the other leaves off--the expectations make it harder for me to integrate "female" gestures and behavior into everyday actions.

Some of it happens anyway, though. It's not embarrassing to me, maybe because I want the rewards of it enough so that I don't care how it comes about. At 54, I know I'm not immortal. While I think that I have quite a bit of time left, I also know that I want to get on with living as fully as I can, right now.

Thanks again for the post, Maggie. It's good to see you again.

Posted: Tue Aug 02, 2005 4:04 pm
by Loretta Ann
When I am Maggie I am able to love myself. Now, if I could only learn to do this as a man.
Hi Maggie,

Maybe it is because I am to simple minded but I have never been able to see myself as being anything more than one person who at one time wanted to become a woman. Who is now quite satisfied to settle for wearing their clothes.

For me loving myself means simply that. Loving me as I am includes all of who I am. One package in one body. I am unable to grasp the torment this must cause those who are not able to see it as such. To have to fight with oneself as well as their creator in this way must be hard indeed.

I am really sorry I don’t have any answers I have not had to deal with the issue. For me it has meant loving all of me or nothing. I am unable to get my head around it being any other way. I simply do not understand how it is possible to think that one is able to love themselves while at the same time rejecting, apart of who they are which can only translate into repression.

Love,
Darlene.

Posted: Tue Aug 02, 2005 5:12 pm
by Maggie
Darlene wrote:Maybe it is because I am to simple minded but I have never been able to see myself as being anything more than one person who at one time wanted to become a woman. Who is now quite satisfied to settle for wearing their clothes.
No, you're not "simple minded." You're just different from me. I don't have any intrinsic desire to become a woman per se, or to wear women's clothing for their own sake. I just need to experience the good feelings and self love that reside in Maggie - a separate persona that became split off because of the abuse I suffered as a child, and which just happens to be female. In order to enjoy these positive feelings (including sexual release, by the way) I must completely divorce myself from my male persona and identify with Maggie. I don't like being stuck in this situation, but that's where I am right now.

Posted: Tue Aug 02, 2005 5:59 pm
by Virginia
Maggie,
I can identify with your being Maggie for Maggie. That is the way I am with Virginia. She has to be and that means that I gotta be. I know Darlene has mentioned in other threads that that is just not her and she has trouble grasping how we (you and I ) feel toward Maggie and Virginia. but I know how I feel and based on what you have said I understand how you feel. I do not however understand when you say that, you "don't like being stuck in this situation......." Honey we part company there, cause I Love IT!
Just keep the faith, girlfriend!
Virginia

Posted: Tue Aug 02, 2005 6:11 pm
by Anne
Hi Maggie, it is good to see you "down the road" in your quest, having read your story from your first post on.

We all continue to travel, may yours be towards understanding, acceptance, & happiness.

Anne

Posted: Tue Aug 02, 2005 8:54 pm
by Maggie
Virginia wrote:I do not however understand when you say that, you "don't like being stuck in this situation......." Honey we part company there, cause I Love IT!
Sure, I love being Maggie. It would be a lot easier if I could make her a regular part of my life. Unfortunately, my wife abhors my crossdressing, and I am not about to risk a divorce.

Posted: Tue Aug 02, 2005 9:58 pm
by Virginia
:oops: Now I understand Maggie. Just hang in there!
Love,
Virginia

Posted: Wed Aug 03, 2005 12:54 am
by Sallee
Maggie
Interesting comment about risking divorce to intergrate Maggie more into your life. I find the same problem. I know my wife is not thrilled with Sallee and I can understand that. She enjoyed Sallee's company more when we were younger and B4 kids. It was more of a novelty then I think. She puts up with my alter ego now, cloths hang in the closet but I don't push it and don't talk about it.(not healthy). I real should work to intergrate it more even en drab and I try to do that realizing that both men & women have to function and therfore are essentially the same.
I am starting to get heavy :? here and I much perfer to have fun :)
I really have no suggestions other than what you mentioned integrate all parts of us into ourselves and that is our true self :-k
Any way Have fun.....Sallee